A note to consider
With shares trading as though Hertz were a near-bankrupt enterprise, an unsecured note maturing in the next three weeks trades at 95–97. Such an instrument as the note is a rather straightforward play with a principal amount (unsecured by collateral in this case), a coupon, and a payment schedule. Hertz has been in turmoil for quite some time since the bankruptcy without a successful turnaround. But will the dues be paid in December, or is the risk priced efficiently?
Value investors have probably heard of Hertz’s doom-and-gloom story, and Bill Ackman, the well-known value investor, invested in the company in 2024. After Hertz emerged from bankruptcy back in 2021, management has made several costly mistakes. The most important was the investment in EVs, which led to a disastrous devaluation of its fleet. As Hertz had just come out of bankruptcy, a multi-billion-dollar write-off was not what you would hope for. With a share price dropping from almost $27 in 2021 to $1.45 in 2026, it is clear that the market anticipates a near-term bankruptcy, with Reddit commentators discussing the short squeeze.
“Heads I win, tails I don’t lose much” – Monish Pabrai
Such a capital-intensive business that requires leverage at its core to finance its cash-flow-producing assets is not an interesting investment for us. Nevertheless, its outstanding notes might be an opportunity to play a simple value game. Of the initial $500m note issued in 2021, $200m is left to be repaid on 1 December 2026. Three weeks from maturity, we would expect the note to trade at par if Hertz remains a going concern. With the short squeeze and negative outlook, investors want to stay away from the company. In 2028 and 2029, Hertz has to repay major loans, which seems impossible given its current position and developments. Several of Hertz’s investors have hired independent advisors to figure out their next move. While Hertz’s cash flow statement is far from that of a healthy cash-flow-producing company, its balance sheet provides comfortable reassurance for the December repayment. Even with a cash-burning bear case in mind, a repayment seems likely. In Hertz’s latest earnings call in early November, the CFO (whom we haven’t assessed for trustworthiness, and whose words we therefore take with a grain of salt) confirmed the repayment in December.
A real risk to this bond is a board-initiated bankruptcy before the repayment, or within 90 days after it. In the latter case, a claim could be made against the bondholders, provided Hertz had repaid the note while insolvent. Assessing Hertz’s financials and possible scenarios, we cannot find a straight path towards insolvency within this period. This leaves us with a potential board-initiated bankruptcy before the repayment. Although this remains a risk, we have not been able to find any information pointing towards such an action. With an ask price of 95.38 and full repayment, we would make nearly 5% within three weeks (±100% annualised), but with a downside of 50% or more.
With expected year-end liquidity of $800m, expected positive free cash flow in 2027, and a managerial approach of financing operations internally, this seems to be an efficiently priced probability bet within the set timeframe rather than a value play. With a great downside and only a respectable upside, the bet still goes against one of our principles: a protected downside. Therefore, we have decided to pass on this opportunity.
Disclaimer: This publication is intended for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute personalised investment advice, nor an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security. It reflects the author’s opinions, estimates and analysis as of the date of publication, based on information believed to be reliable but not guaranteed for accuracy or completeness. Investing involves risk, including the loss of capital. The author may hold positions in the securities discussed; any material positions, compensation or other conflicts of interest will be disclosed in the relevant publication. Readers should conduct their own research and reach their own investment decisions.
Related Insights